Italy accidentally legalizes some P2P music

Italy accidentally legalizes some P2P music
It seems that Italian parliament has inadvertently legalized some music sharing over P2P networks.

The new copyright law, which was passed by both houses of the parliament allows Italians to share all the music they want over the internet as long as it is "noncommercial" and the music is "degraded" in terms of quality.



The original piece, printed in the Italian newspaper la Republica quotes Italian copyright attorney Andrea Monti as saying that "whoever authored the law failed to take into account that the word 'degraded' has a 'very precise meaning'." Currently, music sold on all major legal alternatives is degraded, usually to 192kbps MP3 or 128kbps AAC. The new law means that Italian music fans will be able to share their music libraries over P2P networks as long as it is not lossless.

Despite the fact that the law limits such sharing to "educational or scientific" use, Monti feels it will make prosecuting P2P users more difficult.

If Italian lawmakers decide that the new law is not such a good idea they would have to go through all the process of passing another law. The current legislation cannot be altered "needing only publication in the Official Journal before becoming law."




Written by: Andre Yoskowitz @ 2 Feb 2008 16:57
Advertisement - News comments available below the ad
  • 17 comments
  • bogwart16

    Quello č divertente!

    2.2.2008 17:14 #1

  • SamNz

    haha well done italy

    2.2.2008 17:23 #2

  • david89

    good job Italy hope more countrys follow.

    2.2.2008 22:27 #3

  • david89

    good job Italy hope more countrys follow.

    2.2.2008 22:27 #4

  • nobrainer

    everything should be free for educational purposes, how the hell does a civilisation advance anyway(rhetorical question), by building on ideas and works that already exist obviously, but big media wants a piece of every pie just like the mafia protection racket.

    big media really makes me sick to the gut with how the thwart society from advancement and i will never again purchase any new media, its all 2nd hand movies/games/music for me from now, hit these companies where it hurts.

    The BPI Are: SONY, UNIVERSAL, WARNER GROUP, EMI.

    The RIAA Soundexchange Are: SONY, UNIVERSAL, WARNER GROUP, EMI.

    The MPAA Are: SONY, UNIVERSAL, WARNER GROUP, DISNEY, PARAMOUNT, FOX.

    3.2.2008 04:32 #5

  • DXR88

    HEh. accidently Hahahaha, yes the pirate bay's new location Italy...

    but i wonder how long this will last for italy. with the Nazi/Mafia/gestopo troops on there way riding on the politions backs with there lawyer servant polishing there golden toilets.

    Time will tell all

    3.2.2008 10:31 #6

  • Amir89

    Wow, the Italians set yet another standard for the world to follow..
    Go Italy!

    Current Specs:
    Intel82801BA Mobo, Intel D 945G @3.4Ghz, 2x2Mb L2 Cache, 1Gb DDR2 SD RAM @677Mhz, 250Gb WD Caviar @10,000Rpm, GeForce7600GT 512MB GDDR2, ASUSTek Tiger Digital/Analog TV Tuner, Samsung SyncMaster941BW 19" LCD, LG H20L DVD±R/RW DL LightScribe, LG GSA-4167B DVD±R/RW DL, Logitech Z-5500 505Watt 5.1 Surround


    3.2.2008 11:26 #7

  • Ghostdog

    But if this is only limited to "non-commercial music", I guess that rules out everything released by a label or on CD´s.

    3.2.2008 13:21 #8

  • ZippyDSM

    I get it so if I trade music i a non noncommercial setting I can share any music!

    3.2.2008 13:52 #9

  • Unfocused

    So, hypothetically speaking, if I was having a debate with somebody whether The Beatles produced better music than Elvis, would sharing the music of either artist classify as “educational or scientific” for the purpose of a “debate?”

    3.2.2008 18:57 #10

  • drach

    all music is educational if you want to learn the lyrics.

    4.2.2008 00:43 #11

  • psplvanub

    except from eminem, 50 cent, and a 100 other rap artists.
    took the wordsbright out of your mouth, didnt i, drach?

    oh yea OMG FMAO LOL ITALY

    7.2.2008 12:18 #12

  • borhan9

    Love your work Italy. Italian Opera music to my ears :)

    23.2.2008 17:17 #13

  • psxnut

    In the words of the famous Charlie Crocker.
    "Molto Bene pop"

    31.3.2008 05:03 #14

  • Ghostdog

    Quote:oh yea OMG FMAO LOL ITALY What the hell?

    1.4.2008 04:21 #15

  • iluvendo

    Only the Italians!!! Viva la Italianos!!!

    If it wasn't for bad luck, I'd have no luck!
    "The flimsier the product,the higher the price"
    Ferengi 82nd rule of aquisition

    1.4.2008 16:07 #16

  • 7thsinger

    Quote:oh yea OMG FMAO LOL ITALY
    WTF?

    Ahh, leave it to the Italians!







    "Sir, i would not harm thee for the world...but thou art standing where i'm about to shoot."

    1.4.2008 16:14 #17

© 2024 AfterDawn Oy

Hosted by
Powered by UpCloud