AfterDawn: News

Federal court says UMG can't stop the sale of promo CDs

Last year Universal Music Group (UMG) filed a lawsuit against Troy Augusto claiming he was violating copyright law by offering promotional CDs for sale. Now a federal district court has ruled that UMG's copyright wasn't violated by the sales.

At issue is the legal force of warnings on the CDs, which were sent (free of charge) to radio stations. UMG claimed that since they weren't actually sold the first sale doctrine, which allows you to do what you please with goods you've purchased, has no application. The court ruled that the CDs are given as gifts, which in turn means the first sale doctrine does apply and UMG has no say in whether they're sold later.



The court's decision may also be important in the case of Timothy Vernor. Vernor is suing AutoCAD developer Autodesk for repeatedly interfering with his right to sell legally purchased copies of their software through eBay. Autodesk's argument has been that the licensing agreement for AutoCAD makes resale a copyright violation.

This is simlar to UMG's claim that by simply adding wording to a CD they effectively negated the first sale right.

Written by: Rich Fiscus @ 12 Jun 2008 5:13

• Previous article

• Nokia to bring touchscreens to a wide range of phones

• Next article

• Orange opens music download store

• 8 comments

• spiesfan

  ha ha

  12.6.2008 10:07 #1

• nobrainer

  Originally posted by spiesfan: ha haexactly, lol.
  
  its a case of, "this is yours but you're not allowed to sell it", kinda rings of media licensing, the great system that is not anti-consumer in any way shape or form, Universal just think they can treat physical media the same, but what do you expect from any riaa/mpaa member!
  
  

  The BPI Are: SONY, UNIVERSAL, WARNER GROUP, EMI.
  The RIAA Soundexchange Are: SONY, UNIVERSAL, WARNER GROUP, EMI.
  The IFPI Are: The same anti consumer lot as listed above!
  The MPAA Are: SONY, UNIVERSAL, WARNER GROUP, DISNEY, PARAMOUNT, FOX.

  12.6.2008 11:39 #2

• grkblood

  meh...

  12.6.2008 11:58 #3

• ZippyDSM

  all of the not for sale/resale lables is a joke.

  12.6.2008 12:04 #4

• iluvendo

  Troy Augusto +5
  UMG -10

  12.6.2008 14:48 #5

• DXR88

  Troy Augusto uses but its promotional,Giant Enemy UMG Takes massive damage.

  12.6.2008 16:18 #6

• o0cynix0o

  Quote:UMG claimed that since they weren't actually sold the first sale doctrine, which allows you to do what you please with goods you've purchased, has no application.
  
  Universal needs to remember this when they want to sue some one. And what are they going to do to all the second hand stores that sell CD's and DVD's???

  12.6.2008 21:17 #7

• susieqbbb

  I could understand this with Autodesk autocad due to fake serials and illegal serials to there autocad suite but if the person decides to sell the software at a garage sale or a goodwill or other thrift store.
  
  What the heck are they going to due thrift stores do not fall under this no resale bull

  13.6.2008 01:17 #8